The Pierces' sophomore album, Light of the Moon, was released in August 2004. The girls recorded this album with Brian Sperber after being signed to Universal Records. A Way To Us was the only single from the album, but Save Me was a very popular track due to it's previous appearance on the TV show Roswell. The Pierces personally don't like this album, and have said that their "music was lost in the production" and that "the record sounded more like his (Brian) than ours"
Tracklisting:
1. The Space Song- 4:28 (Written by: Allison Pierce, Catherine Pierce, & Brian Sperber)
2. Tonight- 4:17 (Written by: Allison Pierce & Catherine Pierce)
3. Save Me- 4:00 (Written by: Allison Pierce, Catherine Pierce, Brian Sperber, Jimmy Collins, & Matt Brownlewee)
4. Patience- 3:49 (Written by: Allison Pierce & Catherine Pierce)
5. A Way To Us- 3:30 (Written by: Allison Pierce, Catherine Pierce, & Brian Sperber)
6. Louisa- 4:05 (Written by: Allison Pierce & Catherine Pierce)
7. Give It All Back- 4:51 (Written by: Allison Pierce & Catherine Pierce)
8. Beautiful Thing- 3:44 (Written by: Allison Pierce, Catherine Pierce, & Joe Pisapia)
9. You're Right- 3:12 (Written by: Allison Pierce, & Catherine Pierce)
10. I Don't Mind- 4:13 (Written by: Allison Pierce, Catherine Pierce, & Brian Sperber)
11. I Should've Known- 3:57 (Written by: Allison Pierce & Catherine Pierce)